How much is a hand worth?

$100,000? $200,000? More? How much more? More than the amount of money that is allegedly unaccounted for in the former AHPETC?

An old lady had to suffer the trauma of losing her hand after it got stuck between lift doors. I hope that her family, loved ones and all those who care for her can give her the courage and support to recover from this incident.

The family members are, rightfully, demanding answers. Was it simply an “unfortunate” incident? Could it have been prevented? Were there lapses in maintenance? Apparently the lift had undergone some maintenance the week before the incident happened. Did something go wrong during the maintenance? How could that have happened? Could the Town Council have done anything to have prevented it?

Some unsympathetic people who seem to lack the capacity for empathy have called the family members who are rightfully demanding answers whining babies. They feel that an accident happened, the lady, the family and the rest of Singapore should just accept it and move on. I am worried that there are Singaporeans who are so unsympathetic amongst us.

Then there are those who are a little more moderate. These are saying that since investigations are ongoing, we should not speculate. We should let the investigation run its course. I hope that we will indeed get full and frank answers. And if there are indeed any lapses, the people responsible (or rather irresponsible people) will be suitably punished. I hope that all town councils will learn from this incident so that everything is done to prevent such incidents from ever happening.

Not surprisingly, this issue has also been politicised. Of course, this has raised the ire of many PAP supporters who have asked that this issue not to be politicised. That is really the pot calling the kettle black. It was the PAP who made everything that had anything to do with Town Councils a political issue. PAP started it and now that something went wrong in their Town Councils, their supporters ask people not to politicise the incident? Very funny.

So I hope that this will also make PAP more humble in dealing with AHTC. Anyone and everyone can make mistakes. There has still not been any evidence of criminal wrongdoing (e.g. corruption) regarding the AHPETC accounts, I would conclude that whatever issues AHPETC had with their accounts were administrative mistakes. Grave as that mistake may be, as far as I know, the opposition run town councils of the past had not had any incidents that resulted in people losing their limbs. So I hope that before PAP MPs and supporters comment about opposition run town councils (now only one, AHTC), they would remember this incident and know that they too are not infallible, that shit happens in their own town councils too.

So. How much is a hand worth? If this had happen during the campaigning period of GE, would it have cost PAP another GRC and a few SMCs? We don’t know. But I am certain that a hand, beyond monetary compensation, is at least worth some answers, some introspection, some humility to learn what went wrong and make necessary improvements in process.

[Featured image: From ChannelNewsAsia website, photo by Ngau Kai Yan]


4 thoughts on “How much is a hand worth?

  1. The muted press coverage on this issue, is telling as well. Can you imagine if this had happened in AHTC? I’ve not seen any press release from the current Minister for National Development as well.

    As I’ve said previously, Singaporeans are getting more apathetic to others’ plight.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. RC

    Will call you out on the AHPETC accounts, they are not administrative mistakes when more than 20% of expenses (estimated) as by their own auditors cannot be accounted for or documented for the past 4-5 years, in the commercial world, people will be fired for such mistakes.
    As you just wish to whitewash everything which WP does, will just take your opinions as such even using such tragic accidents in which people are waiting for answers to the queries and there are such things as accidents in which this was clearly one considering.
    Frankly, this is tiring and resulted in many voters especially in such uncertain climes to be turned off, where every bad thing even as a result of mechanical failure (eg road accidents) is blamed on the govt whilst every good thing is a result of the opposition.
    Continue on such tracks and lets see the results.

    For the tragic accident, my sympathies to the family and will await the investigation results which may have been due unseen mechanical fatigue.


    • I haven’t whitewashed WP’s mistakes. They were mistakes. No doubt about it. But were those deliberate mistakes or, to use the phrase PAP politician used in the past, an honest mistake?

      I mean… In some countries, having a known terrorist escape your detention cell is reason enough for the minister to be fired. In some countries (and almost definitely in the corporate world), having the budget of a major event almost quadruple from about SGD100million to close to SGD400million, and have volunteers suffer food poisoning when helping out in the event would have been reason for the person in charge to be fired. In the corporate world, people who were responsible for losing the amount of money that some of the Town Councils did in 2008 were fired.

      So unless and until there is clear evidence that the AHPETC issue involved anything criminal, I will still call it an administrative lapse, never mind the consequence such a lapse would have attracted in the corporate world (since even the PAP politicians aren’t judged and punished with the same standards as people in the corporate world).

      Also, was this incident truly an unforeseeable, unpreventable accident? Or was it something tt cld hv been prevented? True, now we still don’t know. And I am not (currently) pinning this on the PAP or the G. This post is merely stating that PAP needs some humility and remember that things can go wrong in their own turf too.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s